In the age of AI, books will endure and libraries matter more than ever

This past weekend, I attended the Napa Valley Book Festival’s Uncork Your Next Great Read event at Blue Oak School. Presented by the Napa Valley Writers branch of the California Writers Club, the event brought together an impressive number of writers sharing their books with the community, along with organizations dedicated to spreading the joy of reading. It was a lot of fun, and a reminder of just how much human creativity continues to astound me. I love discovering new things, so events like this are always a welcome opportunity.
But amid all that creativity, one subject came up that I know is weighing on many writers’ minds: artificial intelligence (AI).
There’s certainly plenty of discussion about how AI might make our lives better. I doubt there’s anyone who hasn’t, at least once, asked ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude to help solve a problem, such as, “What can I do to get my fingers apart after accidentally pouring superglue all over them?” But much of the broader conversation has focused on AI taking jobs, harming the environment and further stratifying the mind bogglingly wealthy from everyone else.
Libraries have been part of this conversation for years. At Napa County Library, we hold an annual staff training day on the first Friday in December, closing our locations so employees can come together for training on a variety of topics.
In 2023, one of our sessions focused on AI in libraries. ChatGPT had only been released to the public the previous November, and while most people weren’t yet talking about it, it was already generating considerable buzz among information professionals. We discussed potential changes to library services and practical applications, but also considered how AI might affect the hands-on, highly personalized assistance libraries provide.
Of course, libraries have weathered similar questions before. When the internet became commonplace, people asked why anyone would need a library. Then Amazon came along. Then Google. And now, with AI becoming part of everyday life, we’re hearing the same question again.
Yet libraries continue to thrive. Statistics show that younger generations are using libraries more than older ones, and overall usage has rebounded since the pandemic. We’re even seeing an influx of new users as economic uncertainty makes the value of borrowing rather than buying increasingly attractive. “Why buy when you can borrow?”
AI as a library tool
The question of whether AI will make libraries obsolete is only one part of a much larger conversation. AI is already being incorporated into many of the online resources libraries provide. Some applications are clearly beneficial while others are less impressive, and some are still too new for me to have an opinion.
One area where AI is making a positive difference is in online research tools, including newspaper databases and other information platforms. AI can improve search results by better understanding what people are actually looking for. Rather than relying solely on exact keywords, language models can interpret natural-language questions and help users find more relevant information. These tools can also be updated continuously, rather than waiting for traditional software updates.
Another promising application is in legal research. When people visit the Napa County Law Library, many are unfamiliar with the resources available to them. Laws are complicated, filled with specialized language and constantly changing. AI-assisted search can help people locate relevant information and explain complicated material in terms they can better understand.
But there are important caveats. AI can confidently present incorrect information or even invent facts, a problem commonly referred to as an “AI hallucination.” The consequences can be particularly serious in legal settings. Hundreds of documented cases have involved fabricated legal citations appearing in court filings, including more than 200 in 2025 alone.
This brings to mind something every student has heard throughout their education: cite your sources. It’s more important than ever to double-check what you’re reading and verify that the information is accurate.
Making information more accessible
Another area where I see enormous potential is AI’s ability to make information available in different formats and languages.
Those who have read more than a couple of my articles know that I have a son with a disability that prevents him from reading. He listens to several audiobooks each month. The challenge, of course, is that he can only listen to a book if an audiobook version exists.
AI is beginning to change that. It can make it possible to turn books into listenable audio without the time and expense traditionally required to produce an audiobook. Just a few years ago, this wasn’t a realistic option. His school once provided access to text-to-speech software as an accommodation, but the results were virtually unlistenable. Think Speak & Spell, [AAP1] only applied to a college-level textbook.
The possibilities extend beyond audiobooks. Relatively few books are translated from English into Spanish or French, German, Tagalog, etc. and vice versa. Fewer still are then made available in audio format. AI could help bring those works to a much larger community of readers and listeners who otherwise might never have access to them.
There is a trade-off, however. An audiobook is almost always better when narrated by a real person who can convey emotion and personality. But if the choice is between a computer-generated voice and no audiobook at all, I’m not convinced that nothing is the better option. Will the public decide computer voices are “good enough,” or will listeners continue to demand human narrators? I don’t know, but it’s a question we’re already having to grapple with. One of our most popular services, Hoopla, has more than 30,000 AI narrated audiobooks. We recently removed them from our patron’s view because the quality wasn’t great. However, in a couple years, it’ll be important for us to reevaluate that position.
What’s next?
We’ve only scratched the surface of what AI might offer. Our household owns a pair of Meta Ray-Ban smart glasses, and they’re nothing short of amazing. You can look around a room and ask the glasses to describe what they see. The results are impressive.
Consider a service called Be My Eyes, which connects people who have low vision or difficulty reading with hundreds of thousands of volunteers through live video. Volunteers can help with everything from navigating a grocery store to identifying items around the house. AI-powered tools, including those available through Meta, can take that assistance a step further by not only describing what’s in front of someone but also explaining it.
I see this kind of technology having an expanding role in library services. Imagine being able to explore a subject, ask follow-up questions and access increasingly detailed information without having to navigate multiple resources or databases. The library’s role as a learning center could expand well beyond the expertise of its staff. Librarians would remain essential, serving as guides, connecting people with reliable information and helping them navigate an increasingly complex information landscape.
The more things change…
One thing I don’t see happening anytime soon is AI replacing books. The majority of library use still revolves around physical materials, and there’s plenty of evidence that people continue to value tangible items and shared experiences. Our Library of Things (LOT) collection continues to grow because it’s something the public has embraced. If anything, I expect that trend to continue.
Using AI to help sort through an overwhelming inbox is one thing. Replacing human connection, experiential learning and the value of public spaces is another. Those are things people seem to want more of, not less.
At some point, another technology or service will undoubtedly come along and prompt people to ask, “Do we still need libraries?” It’s a question we’ve heard many times before, and I’m sure we’ll hear it again.
But for now, I’m confident the answer will remain a resounding “Yes!”
Yountville
The Yountville Library is open Tuesday to Saturday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Call the library at (707) 944-1888.
Contact the author at Anthony.halstead@countyofnapa.org.
Questions or suggestions for the Yountville Library? Contact your commissioner, myrnadavid2014@gmail.com.
Learn more about Friends of the Yountville Library by reaching out to yountvillefol@gmail.com.
