On My Mind: Fifty years later, a Thanksgiving toast to two old friends
A golden anniversary, and Thanksgiving, are on my mind this week in a rather roundabout way.
I realized this year marks the 50th anniversary of the Judgment of Paris. At that blind tasting in the City of Light, an English wine merchant pitted some of France’s finest wines against some of California’s best. At the time, California wines rarely appeared on wine lists or in oenophiles’ cellars.
The American wines won top honors in both the red and white categories evaluated by the mostly French judges. It was quite scandalous in France and astounding in the U.S.
You may have seen the movie Bottle Shock.I suggest the book, Judgment of Paris, by George M. Taber instead. Taber was the only reporter present to cover the event.
Many of us Napa Valley locals know that story well. Some of us even had the privilege of knowing the two winemakers who crafted the winning California wines: Warren Winiarski and Mike Grgich. They both received their mail at the Yountville Post Office for many years, although neither resided within the town limits.
Both of them died in recent years. I have fond memories of both men to share.
I became acquainted with Mike before my late husband, Oscar, and I started the Yountville Sun. Oscar was running around town introducing himself to people, when he met Mike downtown. Oscar told him about our plans for a newspaper and mentioned I had writing experience.
The next thing I knew I was in Mike’s kitchen composing a letter for him to the Napa Valley Register on an issue he was opposing in an upcoming election. We were solid friends from the get-go.
Warren would call me to correct mistakes he detected in the Sun. Sometimes he would have an employee do this, but eventually he just rang me up. Very early one deadline morning I was still struggling to put the “paper to bed,” as they say, and the phone rang. Thinking it was the pressman calling to pressure me into finishing up, I yelled into the phone, “I’m just about done.”
It was Warren on the other end. He was calling to announce to me that he and his wife had decided to donate a very large sum of money to The Pathway Home, a successful program for veterans returning from the service who were experiencing PTSD. I was on the board for that organization at the time. He forgave me for yet another mistake; he read the Sun regularly and appreciated that the community had its own newspaper!
As I got to thinking about what wine I will serve to my family this Thanksgiving, the Paris tasting came to mind. What a fitting way to honor those winning winemakers a half century later. There will be Grgich Hills Chardonnay with the turkey. After the pumpkin pie, I plan to serve a glass of Stag’s Leap Cabernet Sauvignon with a box of chocolates.
As they say in France, “Bon appetit.”